Skip to content

Every high is paid for with a low

The brain answers every spike in pleasure with a dip on the other side. Repeat the spike often enough and the dip becomes your normal, which is why ordinary life starts to feel flat.

5 min read

Contents6 sections
  1. The see-saw
  2. When the low becomes normal
  3. Two voices
  4. Most habits start as a way out of pain
  5. Getting the see-saw level again
  6. Related reading

"All addictions are a game of pleasure and pain in the brain." That line comes from one of the most widely shared threads our founder, Manish Shetty, has written on X, and it's still the simplest way into how habits like porn, drinking, weed and endless scrolling take hold.

The see-saw

Think of your brain's reward system as a see-saw that likes to sit level. Something pleasurable pushes one end up. As soon as that happens, the brain pushes back the other way to bring things level again. And it doesn't stop at level. It overshoots a little toward the low side, and then slowly drifts back.

Psychologists Richard Solomon and John Corbit described this in the 1970s as opponent-process theory. Every strong feeling sets off an opposite reaction that outlasts it. The rush is followed by a comedown. The relief is followed by a flatness.

Once in a while, that's fine. The see-saw comes back to level and life goes on. The trouble starts when you push the same end up, hard, over and over.

When the low becomes normal

Do something that floods the reward system every day, for months or years, and the brain adapts to protect itself. It turns down its own sensitivity, partly by reducing the receptors that dopamine works through. Brain imaging studies have found fewer of a key type of dopamine receptor in people with long-term addictions.

The result is that the see-saw's resting point shifts. Without the habit, you sit below level. You're flat, restless and irritable, and the only thing that reliably lifts you back up is the habit. So the habit stops being something you do to feel good and becomes something you do to feel normal.

That's also why ordinary life starts to look dull. Work, exercise, a good conversation or a quiet evening can't compete with the size of the hits you've been getting, so they barely register. Many people describe it as nothing being exciting anymore. Life didn't get worse. The scale you measure it on got stretched, so ordinary things look small.

Two voices

One way to picture the loop is as two voices in your head. One keeps saying, "I'm never satisfied." The other keeps saying, "I've got just the thing you want." The first is the low end of the see-saw. The second is the habit offering to lift it. And every time you take the offer, the low end sinks a little further afterwards, which keeps both voices talking.

Most habits start as a way out of pain

It's easy to assume people get hooked because they love the feeling. In our experience, that's rarely how it goes. Most people get into these habits to escape something: stress, boredom, loneliness, a bad week, a bad feeling they don't want to sit with. Once they find that a substance or a screen takes the edge off, they come back for more.

But the habit doesn't remove the pain. It numbs you to it for a while and replaces it with craving. What started as a way out of a bad feeling becomes a new source of one.

It also means the drug or the behavior matters less than people think. The bottle, the joint, the screen and the scroll are different ways of delivering the same thing to the same system. That's why stopping one and leaning harder on another rarely works for long.

Getting the see-saw level again

The good news is that the brain is built to adapt, and it adapts back. The same process that turned your sensitivity down can turn it back up once the big hits stop. That takes time, often weeks to months, and longer for heavy, long-term use. It isn't a straight line, either. Some weeks feel flat, and that's part of the process.

What helps:

  1. Step back from the big, fast hits, all of them, for a stretch. Not just the main habit, but the ones you'd be tempted to swap in. This gives the system room to recalibrate.
  1. Put steady, smaller rewards back into your day. Exercise, sunlight, sleep, time with people, learning something hard, deep work on something you care about. None of them will feel like much at first. That's the point. You're teaching your brain to register normal-sized rewards again.
  1. Expect the flatness and don't read it as failure. Life without the habit may feel bland for a while. But it's real, and it doesn't keep getting worse the way the habit did.
  1. Look at what you were escaping. If the habit was a way out of stress, loneliness or boredom, that problem needs its own answer, or you'll keep looking for a way out.

The Behavior Control System

Our 90-day program, private and one-on-one, built around your life.

See our programs

Field Notes

One letter a week from the lab.

No spam. Unsubscribe from any letter.