Skip to content

What to do in the first few minutes of a craving

A craving grows when your mind keeps building the picture, and a lot of it is felt in the body. Both give you places to step in that work better than arguing with it.

7 min read

Contents7 sections
  1. Part one: the picture your mind keeps building
  2. Three minutes of Tetris
  3. Make the picture far away
  4. Part two: the craving is in your body
  5. Urge surfing
  6. A sequence for the first few minutes
  7. Related reading

When a craving hits, most people do one thing: they argue with it. "I'm not going to do it. I don't need it." Sometimes that works. Often it doesn't, and the reason is worth understanding, because there are better places to step in.

A craving has two parts most people never separate. There's what your mind is doing, which is building a picture. And there's what your body is doing, which is a set of physical feelings you've learned to treat as an order. You can work on both.

Part one: the picture your mind keeps building

When you're trying to stop a habit, a craving rarely stays a passing thought. Within a few seconds you're picturing it: a drink being poured, a screen lighting up in the dark, the first hit of the vape. The more clearly you picture it, the harder it is to say no.

The psychologists David Kavanagh, Jackie Andrade and Jon May set out a theory of how this works. It has a complicated name, Elaborated Intrusion theory, and the paper that set it out has a memorable title: "Imaginary relish and exquisite torture." The idea itself is simple.

First, a thought about the habit pops into your head. Something set it off, a place or a feeling, and you didn't choose it. Then your mind starts to build on it. You imagine how it'll taste or feel, where you'd do it and how you'd feel afterwards. Each detail makes the picture more vivid, and the more vivid it gets, the stronger the craving gets. The imagining is what feeds it.

The catch is that your mind only has a small amount of room for this kind of picture. Give it a different picture to work on and there's less room left for the craving.

Three minutes of Tetris

That's why researchers at the University of Plymouth tested Tetris, a game that keeps your mind busy with shapes and where they'll fit. In one study, people who were craving something either played Tetris for three minutes or watched a screen that claimed the game was loading and never did. The people who played said their cravings were weaker afterwards, and less vivid.

Then they took it into everyday life. For a week, a group of students carried a phone with Tetris on it, and several times a day the researchers texted to ask whether they were craving anything. Sometimes the students played for three minutes and sometimes they didn't. When they played, their cravings dropped by about a fifth. That held for food and coffee, cigarettes and alcohol, and things like sex and sleep.

Three minutes of a game won't fix anyone's life, and that isn't the point. What the research shows is that a craving is something your mind keeps building while you have it, and you can get in the way of the building. Arguing with a craving does the opposite, because to argue with it you have to keep holding the picture.

Make the picture far away

There's a second way to change the picture. Researchers at Columbia University found that when smokers thought about the long-term effects of smoking instead of the immediate ones, their cravings dropped, and so did activity in the brain areas linked with craving. Similar work showed children and teenagers could cool their craving for tempting food by imagining it as far away and thinking about its color and shape instead of its taste.

When a habit has been with you for years, your thinking about it is always close up: the taste, the buzz, the relief. Shifting it far away, to the rasping cough, the morning after, the money and the hours, changes what the picture is made of.

Part two: the craving is in your body

A big part of a craving happens below your neck. You feel it in your chest, your stomach, your throat and your hands.

A 2007 study by Nasir Naqvi, Antoine Bechara and colleagues looked at smokers who'd had damage to a small area of the brain called the insula. The insula reads what's going on inside your body, things like your heartbeat, your breathing and how tense your muscles are, and turns all that into feelings you notice. Smokers with damage there were far more likely to quit easily and straight away than smokers with damage elsewhere. One of them reportedly said his body "forgot the urge to smoke."

Nobody is suggesting anything of the kind for you. You need your insula. But the finding tells you what you're up against. Arguing doesn't do much against a feeling in your body, because the feeling doesn't listen to reasons.

Urge surfing

What helps instead is noticing the craving as physical sensations and watching them rise and fall, without acting on them and without fighting them. The psychologist Alan Marlatt called this urge surfing. Every urge has a build-up, a peak and a fade.

In a 2009 study, Sarah Bowen and Marlatt taught urge surfing to student smokers. It didn't make their cravings weaker. They still felt them. But over the following week, the group that learned it smoked fewer cigarettes. The link between feeling the urge and acting on it had loosened. So the craving doesn't have to go away before you can choose not to act on it.

A sequence for the first few minutes

Put the two parts together and you get a short routine you can practise before you need it.

  1. Stop and name it. Stop what you're doing and say to yourself, "This is a craving." Don't start the argument.
  1. Find it in your body. Where is it? Chest, stomach, throat, hands? Is it tight, hot, buzzing? Watch it the way you'd watch a wave come in. Breathe slowly while you do.
  1. Give your mind a different picture. Have something ready that keeps your hands and attention busy for a few minutes: a puzzle game, a Rubik's cube, a fidget toy, sudoku, a set of push-ups or a walk. Carry it before you need it, because a craving won't wait while you go looking.
  1. Push the picture far away. Think about five ways the habit is costing you: your health, your relationships, your money, your mornings.
  1. Delay it. Tell yourself you'll decide in fifteen minutes, not now. By the time the fifteen minutes are up, the craving has usually peaked and started to fall.
  1. Release the tension. If your body is wound up, lie down and work through progressive muscle relaxation: tense one muscle group for five to ten seconds, then let it go, from your face down to your feet. A lot of people use their habit to get rid of tension. This does it without the habit.

Once you've practised it enough, turn it into an if-then rule: if a craving hits, then I run this sequence. With repetition it stops needing a decision.

None of this makes cravings disappear on day one. They'll still come, sometimes strongly. But a craving you interrupt in the first minute is much easier to get through than one you've spent ten minutes building in your head. And each time you ride one out without feeding it, the next one tends to come back a little weaker.

In the Behavior Control System, these skills belong to the second phase, after clients have mapped their triggers and learned to notice the moment a craving starts. They practise them on purpose, so they're familiar when it matters.

The Behavior Control System

Our 90-day program, private and one-on-one, built around your life.

See our programs

Field Notes

One letter a week from the lab.

No spam. Unsubscribe from any letter.