Why one relapse feels like it wiped out your whole life
When the only thing you're working on is quitting a habit, one relapse can feel like it wiped out your whole life, and there's a real reason it feels that way.
When the only thing you're working on is quitting a habit, one relapse can feel like it wiped out your whole life. It didn't, but there's a real reason it feels that way.
We see this over and over again. A guy is a few weeks into stopping and doing everything right. Then he has one bad night and gives in.
The next morning, he doesn't just think "I relapsed." He thinks "I'm a failure, I'll never change, so what's the point of any of it?" After one night, his whole sense of who he is falls apart.
So why does one relapse hit so hard?
Here's some real science to explain it.
Psychologists have studied how many separate sides a person's sense of themselves has. One person might see himself as a father, a runner, a guy who's good at his job, a friend and someone learning guitar. Another person's whole sense of himself rests on one or two things.
In one study, people took a test, and some of them were told they'd done badly. The ones whose sense of themselves had only a few sides took the news much harder, and their mood dropped further. The ones with many sides were knocked less, because the failure only touched one part of who they were.
In a later study, the same researcher followed students through stressful weeks. The ones with fewer sides to themselves reported more depression and more physical illness afterwards, while the ones with more sides seemed to be protected.
Not every study since has found the effect as strongly, and it's not the whole story. But it fits what we see with clients almost perfectly.
Now think about what happens with your habit. When you're trying to stop, it often becomes the biggest thing in your life. You think about it all day, you count the days, and your mood depends on whether you gave in last night.
Without meaning to, you've made your whole sense of yourself rest on one thing. And that one thing is the hardest project you've ever taken on.
So when you relapse, it lands on all of you at once.
That's what makes the next relapse more likely. You feel like a failure, the bad feeling needs somewhere to go, and the habit is the fastest way you know to make it stop.
This is why in phase 1 of our program, every client picks a passion project.
It's something they've always wanted to do, or something they started and gave up on. Clients have picked up drawing, guitar, coding, a language, martial arts, writing and building a business. They practice it every day, and they keep working at getting better.
We tell clients that if they did nothing else on the program but found something like this and gave it their time and attention, we'd count it as a success. The point isn't to fill time. It gives them a second side to who they are that has nothing to do with the habit.
Then in phase 3, we build on it. Each client makes a character sheet of who they want to become, with points for each skill: physical, mental, social, and whatever else they're working on, like guitar or a business. They add points as they get better in real life.
By then, the habit is one small line in a much bigger life, so a bad day only touches one part of you.
We'll be honest with you, a passion project isn't the cure on its own. You still need to deal with your triggers and have a plan for the cravings. BUT it means a relapse no longer has the power to convince you that you're worthless, and that feeling is often what turns one night into a month.
This is how you stop one bad night from becoming who you are.
Sources
- P. W. Linville (1985). Self-complexity and affective extremity: don't put all of your eggs in one cognitive basket. Social Cognition.
- P. W. Linville (1987). Self-complexity as a cognitive buffer against stress-related illness and depression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
The Behavior Control System
Our 90-day program, private and one-on-one, built around your life.
See our programsField Notes
One letter a week from the lab.