Contents12 sections
- Who is this for?
- Step 1: List the moments you always give in
- Step 2: Find the exact thing that gets you in each moment
- Step 3: Pick one thing you'll do instead
- Step 4: Write it as an if-then sentence
- Step 5: Write one for the thought that talks you into it
- Step 6: Rehearse it in your head
- Step 7: Put the plan where the moment happens
- Step 8: Write one for when you've already started
- Step 9: Check your plans every week
- Why does this work?
- Sources
(Works for porn, alcohol, weed, nicotine, scrolling, gambling, any habit. It's what we write with every client once we know their triggers.)
Who is this for?
- You know exactly when you give in. Same time, same place, same feeling, every week
- You promise yourself "next time I'll be stronger", and next time looks exactly like last time
- When the moment comes, your mind goes blank and the habit is the only option you can think of
- Deep down, you think the problem is that you're weak
If this is you, read on.
Giving in at the same moment every week is not a weakness of will.
It's what happens when you walk into your hardest moment with no plan, and try to come up with one on the spot.
Think about how it usually goes..
You get home after a long day. The house is quiet. You're tired, a bit flat, and you know what usually happens next. You tell yourself you won't do it tonight.
But you never decided what you WILL do instead. So you stand there with nothing to do and a craving building, while a tired brain tries to come up with a better idea. It can't, because the habit is the only idea it's had at this time of night for years.
Here's what most people never realize.
Wanting to stop is not enough on its own. Researchers have tested this for decades, and a strong intention only makes a small difference to what people actually do.
What makes a big difference is deciding, in advance, exactly what you'll do when a specific moment arrives.
In one study, people were asked to write a short report about how they spent Christmas and send it in a couple of days later. Half of them were also asked to write down exactly when and where they'd write it. 71% of the people with a plan sent their report in. Only 32% of the people without one did.
And it goes deeper than that..
In another study, people going through withdrawal in a treatment center were asked to write a short resume before 5pm. They all meant to do it, but half of them also wrote down when and where they would. By 5pm, 8 out of the 10 who planned had written theirs. Of the 10 who hadn't planned, none had.
Both groups wanted the same thing, and both were going through withdrawal. The only difference was that one group had decided in advance.
When researchers looked at almost a hundred of these studies together, the effect held up. And it worked especially well for people who struggle to control what they do.
The reason is simple. When you decide in advance "if this happens, then I'll do that", your brain links the moment to the action. So when the moment shows up, you don't have to think about what to do. You start doing it almost without deciding, the same way the habit used to work.
This is called an if-then plan.
This post is not about theory though. Here's exactly how to write yours.
Let's begin.
Step 1: List the moments you always give in
Sit down with a pen and paper on a calm morning. Not the morning after a relapse.
Write down the 3 to 5 moments when you give in most often. Be specific about where you are, what time it is, and what just happened.
- Walking in the door after work, house empty
- In bed with the phone, after 11pm
- Friday night, after a hard week
- Right after an argument with your partner
- Sunday afternoon with nothing planned
If you did the chain analysis from our last post, you already have this list. It's your key links.
Most people find the same few moments keep coming up. That's good news. It means your relapses are predictable, and anything predictable can be planned for.
Step 2: Find the exact thing that gets you in each moment
For each moment, write down what actually makes you want the habit. It's usually a feeling or a thought, not the moment itself.
- Walking in the door: "I'm exhausted and I deserve something"
- In bed: boredom, and the phone already in your hand
- Friday night: "the week's over, I can relax now"
- After an argument: anger you don't know what to do with
Close your eyes and picture the moment for a minute. Where are you standing? What do you feel in your body? What's the first thought? The clearer you see it now, the faster you'll recognize it when it happens.
Step 3: Pick one thing you'll do instead
For each moment, choose ONE action. Just one. Make it specific, physical, and easy enough to do while you're tired.
"Relax" and "be strong" aren't actions. "Go for a 10-minute walk around the block" is.
- Walking in the door: shoes stay on, straight back out for a 10-minute walk, then dinner
- In bed: phone goes on the charger in the kitchen, book on the pillow
- Friday night: plans made by Thursday, out of the house by 7pm
- After an argument: leave the room, cold water on your face, write down what you're angry about
Step 4: Write it as an if-then sentence
Now put each one into this exact form:
"If [the moment], then I will [the action]."
- "If I walk in the door and feel like I deserve something, then I will keep my shoes on and walk around the block for 10 minutes."
- "If it's 10:30pm, then I will put my phone on the charger in the kitchen."
- "If I've just had an argument, then I will leave the room and put cold water on my face."
There's one mistake almost everyone makes here. They put the goal in the "then" part, like "If I feel a craving, then I will stay clean." That's just the wish written out again, and it gives you nothing to do when the craving hits.
The "if" is the moment or the feeling. The "then" is the exact thing your body does.
Step 5: Write one for the thought that talks you into it
Every habit has a sentence that opens the door. "Just this once." "I'll start again on Monday." "I've earned it."
Write an if-then plan for that sentence too.
"If I hear myself say 'just this once', then I will text one person and tell them I'm thinking about it."
You can't stop the thought from showing up. But you can decide now what it's the signal for.
Step 6: Rehearse it in your head
This is the step that makes it stick.
Pick one plan. Close your eyes. Picture the moment as clearly as you can: the room, the time, the feeling building. Then picture yourself doing the action, all the way through. Shoes on, door open, walking.
Do this once for each plan, then read each plan out loud.
Researchers have found that tennis players can improve their serve just by practicing it in their heads, because imagining a movement uses a lot of the same parts of the brain as doing it. You're doing the same thing with your hardest moment, before you're in it.
Step 7: Put the plan where the moment happens
Your plan is no good in a notebook in a drawer.
- The after-work plan goes on a note by the front door
- The bedtime plan goes on your lock screen
- The Friday plan goes in your calendar for Thursday
Read them every morning for the first few weeks. It takes 30 seconds.
Step 8: Write one for when you've already started
Some nights the plan won't work. Plan for that too.
"If I've already started, then I will stop, put it away, and message one person."
One relapse doesn't have to turn into a whole night, or a whole week.
Step 9: Check your plans every week
Once a week, go through each plan. Did the moment come up? Did you do the action? If you didn't, why not?
If the action was too hard, make it easier. If the moment came at a different time, change the "if". If a new moment has shown up, write a new plan.
A plan that didn't work just tells you what to change. Change one thing and try it again next week.
Why does this work?
Because you're making the decision once, in the morning, while you're calm, instead of every night, while you're tired and craving.
When the moment arrives, you're not trying to come up with a better idea. The better idea is already there, and it's linked to the moment. You see the front door, and your feet already know what to do.
The habit worked the same way for years. You're just giving that moment a new job.
Now, be honest with yourself..
This won't make the cravings disappear. Some nights you'll do the action and still want it. And if you can avoid a moment completely, avoid it. Make the habit hard to reach first (that was the first post in this series), then write plans for the moments you can't avoid.
And if you drink heavily every day, talk to a doctor before you stop. Stopping suddenly can be dangerous.
Write your first three plans today. It takes about 30 minutes.
Try it out, it works.
This is part of what we do with clients in phase 1 of our program. Once we've mapped every moment the habit shows up, we write a plan for each one, then test those plans against real days and rewrite the ones that don't hold.
Sources
- Gabriele Oettingen, Rethinking Positive Thinking (Current, 2014)
- P. M. Gollwitzer and V. Brandstätter (1997). Implementation intentions and effective goal pursuit. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
- Marsha M. Linehan, DBT Skills Training Manual, 2nd edition (Guilford Press, 2015)
- G. Alan Marlatt and Dennis M. Donovan (eds.), Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors, 2nd edition (Guilford Press, 2005)
The Behavior Control System
Our 90-day program, private and one-on-one, built around your life.
See our programsField Notes
One letter a week from the lab.
